Mystery Baseball Theme by KearnsT

Question 6

This two-time all-star led the NL in ERA in 2010 and was on pace to do the same in 2011 before he was shelved by a shoulder injury. Having already experienced a career interruption with Tommy John surgery, he recovered to become the first ever starter for the newly-christened Miami Marlins, but would be dumped to the Blue Jays after the club disappointed, alongside high-priced veterans Mark Buehrle and Jose Reyes. After an ugly season in Toronto, injuries have knocked him out of baseball again.

Name this alliterative right-hander, who attempted comebacks with the San Diego Padres but never appeared in the majors, instead undergoing his second and third Tommy John surgeries.

Josh Johnson