Cheers by Consigliari

Question 1

In "Pitch it Again, Sam", Mayday is asked to face an old Yankee nemesis on a day that honors the former pinstriper. After being unable to get him out for his entire career, Sam is eager to strike out his former foe in front of the New York faithful - only to serve one up after being duped. Name this former Yankee who punctuated his homers with his infamous Windmill dance.

Dutch Kincaid