Mystery Theme VIII: Baseball by KlionskyG

Question 12

Of the 18 players pictured below, give the LETTER next to either of the two who most closely fit the theme of this quiz.

Click for additional information

E (Bobby COX), J (WILLIE Stargell). Happy April Fools and Opening Day! At least I didn't use this pitching line from July 5, 2016 Royals game: