Just Music 2018: Round 3 - Failed Followups by DixonD

This American rock band's sole hit from their album Camino Palmero reached #5 in 2001, but dominated the Adult Top 40 chart, and was listed by Billboard as the number one song of the decade on the Adult charts.

Failed followup: "Could It Be Any Harder" (did not chart) (edited at 5:38 pm, August 11, 2018 (EDT))

Original question: This American rock band's sole hit from their album Camino Palmero reached #5 in 2001, but dominated the Adult Top 40 chart, and was listed by Billboard as the number one song of the decade on the Adult charts.

Failed followup: "Wherever You Will Go" (did not chart)

Click for additional information